Material consumed exceeds theoretical requirement by 11.4%. Progress of 92% cannot be reconciled against issue records.
How this verdict was computed
BOQ quantity complete92×0.40
MB pages 180–219 · 5 items
Checklist pass rate88×0.20
stage QA checklist register
RA-bill certified74×0.20
RA-06 certified abstract
NCR burden (inverted)93×0.10
1 NCRs on this floor
Schedule slip (inverted)77×0.10
programme baseline rev 4
Weighted score 86.2. Evidence coverage 81%. Two rules sit above this arithmetic: over 8% material variance or an open critical NCR forces Contradicted; under 30% evidence forces Unobserved regardless of how good the numbers look.
BOQ items on this floor
Item
Planned
Measured
Certified
Verdict
BOQ 4.2
RCC M25 in slabs, beams & landings incl. shuttering and finishing
70
64
50
Supported
BOQ 5.1
Brickwork 230mm thick in CM 1:6 with second class red bricks
69
65
51
Supported
BOQ 6.4
12mm cement plaster in CM 1:4 to internal walls
387
346
273
Supported
BOQ 8.3
Vitrified tile flooring 600×600 laid on 20mm CM 1:4 bed
288
255
201
Supported
BOQ 9.1
APP membrane waterproofing to toilets and terrace incl. screed
376
335
264
Supported
Material reconciliation — theoretical vs actual
Material
Theoretical
Actual
Variance
At risk
OPC 53 cement
store issue register · 3 slips
99.66 bag
111.02 bag
+11.4%
₹4,646
TMT Fe550
store issue register · 4 slips
3.94 T
4.19 T
+6.4%
₹14,600
M-sand
store issue register · 2 slips
36.15 T
38.07 T
+5.3%
₹2,189
20mm aggregate
store issue register · 9 slips
37.01 T
38.86 T
+5.0%
₹1,813
Red brick
store issue register · 8 slips
4,638.57 no
4,800.92 no
+3.5%
₹1,445
Anything above 8% is Contradicted. Cement does not evaporate — it walks out of the gate.